Explainers
Crypto withdrawal fee scams: why paying never releases the money
The scheme ends the same way, whatever it began as. A platform shows a balance that has grown, the holder asks to take it out, and the platform names a payment that has to be made first: a tax on the gains, a commission, an unlocking fee, a verification deposit. The US agencies that have described the pattern agree on what happens next. Paying does not release the money, because there was never money behind the number, and the fee is the scheme’s next deposit rather than an obstacle in front of a real one.
How the scheme runs
The FBI’s public alerts describe one sequence often enough that it can be read as a template. Its March 2023 alert gives the outline. The scheme usually starts as a romance or confidence scam, run under a fictitious identity on a dating app, social media, a professional network or an encrypted messaging app. Once trust is established, the contact claims expertise in crypto and steers the victim to a website or app “controlled by the criminals”, coaches them through investing, shows fake profits and encourages more. “When victims attempt to withdraw their money, they are told they need to pay a fee or taxes.”
The other alerts fill in the stages either side. The balance on the screen is built to impress: the fake sites and apps “give the impression” that the investment is “growing exponentially”, in the FBI’s October 2022 alert. An early withdrawal is often allowed. In the September 2021 alert, the scammers let the victim withdraw a small amount to gain their trust, push for larger deposits with a need to “act fast”, and then find reasons the next withdrawal cannot happen. The FBI’s 2025 annual report adds loans offered to fund bigger deposits, and describes the taxes and fees charged at withdrawal as “a final attempt to exploit money from the victims before the scammers disappear with all the victim funds”. The end, in the 2022 alert, is that the website closes or the contact stops replying.
The same report gives the scale of the wider category it belongs to. In 2025, complaints to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) about cryptocurrency investment fraud numbered 61,559, with $7.228 billion in reported losses, the largest source of reported losses to Americans that year. Those figures cover the whole of the fraud as reported, not only the money paid at the withdrawal stage, and only what victims chose to report to the IC3. The relationship stage has its own piece, pig butchering. Task scams reach the same demand by another route: the FTC describes task apps telling users they must make a deposit to get their supposed earnings out, and adds, “if you deposit money, you won’t get it back” (FTC, December 2024).
The names the payment goes by
The label changes from case to case. The function does not.
One is a tax on the gains: victims are told they “need to pay income taxes or additional fees” to cash out (IC3, 2022). Another is a commission, and the CFTC’s advisory on fee scams describes upfront deposits followed by “ridiculously high commissions, taxes, and fees”. In the 2021 alert the reason is a minimum balance that has not been met, so more must go in before anything can come out. The CFTC’s romance-fraud advisory describes holders “locked out” of their accounts and made to pay, or to have their ID verified, to get any money back. And in the FBI’s June 2026 alert the platform says the account has been “flagged”, couriers collect cash in person, and a later attempt to withdraw meets “fraudulent taxes and penalties”, at which point the scammers “begin the loop over”.
Sometimes a “customer service group” gets involved. The 2021 alert notes that it is “also part of the scam”.
The amount is pitched against the balance, and the CFTC spells out why: “The promise of huge profits is dangled in front of the investors to make the fees and taxes look like a small percentage of what they’ve earned.” A joint SEC and CFTC alert classes the demand for “purported taxes” to withdraw fake profits as advance-fee fraud, in which investors pay a bogus fee in advance of receiving proceeds that do not come.
Why paying never releases the money
Start with what the balance is. A figure inside an app is recorded wherever the operator records it, a point the cloud mining piece makes about mining apps, and on these platforms the operator is the scammer. The deposits went to accounts and addresses the scammers control, often abroad; the joint alert warns that fraudsters “can quickly send your money overseas, with little chance of you being able to get it back”. What is left on the screen is a number generated to encourage the next transfer. The CFTC’s wording is that “in fee scams, the earnings are never real.”
So there is nothing for a payment to unlock. The FBI’s 2023 alert says victims “are unable to get their money back, even if they pay the imposed fees or taxes”, and its alert on fake play-to-earn games, in March 2023, says the same of victims told to pay taxes or fees to reclaim drained funds. What a payment does produce is evidence that the holder will pay, and in the 2026 alert the loop simply starts over: the next attempt to withdraw meets new taxes and penalties.
Three features of the demand give it away, and each follows from there being no real balance behind it.
The fee cannot come out of the balance. A platform holding real funds could deduct any genuine charge from what it pays out, which is how exchange withdrawal fees work, so a demand that the money arrive separately, and first, exists because the balance cannot pay anything. The CFTC counts reasons why fees “can’t be taken from the money” among the warning signs of recovery fraud. The logic is the same here.
The tax is being collected by the wrong party. The CFTC says it does not collect taxes from market customers, does not ask platforms to collect funds on the government’s behalf, and that individuals typically pay tax on trading when they file returns with the IRS. Its fee-scam advisory adds that “U.S. brokers will not collect or withhold taxes from trading accounts.” Those statements describe US rules. Elsewhere the question to put is the same one: who is the tax owed to, and why would it be paid into the platform?
And the payment is wanted in a form that is hard to get back. “Only scammers demand payment in cryptocurrency,” says the FTC. The 2022 FBI alert records victims told to buy large amounts of prepaid cards, and the 2026 one describes couriers collecting cash at victims’ homes or in public places.
A real hold, and how it differs
Genuine platforms do hold withdrawals. A registered exchange checks identity, since anti-money-laundering registration exists for exactly that, as what a regulated exchange is regulated for explains. It may review an unusual transfer. And in the worst case a failing exchange stops withdrawals for every customer at once, the opening stage of the process in what happens when an exchange fails. Real holds are what lend the fake one its plausibility.
The difference is in what is asked for. A genuine check asks for documents or information, through the account and support channels you reached yourself. The fake one asks for money, usually through a contact who arrived with the person who recommended the platform. The CFTC’s fee-scam advisory gives two rules that cover most cases: “Risks, fees, and commissions should always be disclosed before accounts are opened,” and “Never pay more money to withdraw from your own account.” Whether the platform is a registered business at all can be checked in an hour, by the method in how to check if a crypto platform is legitimate.
It is also a different thing from a rug pull, in which a token’s creators drain the liquidity behind a coin that did trade on a public chain. Here the coin in the account may never have existed anywhere outside the platform’s database.
What to do instead of paying
- Stop paying. The FBI’s advice to anyone who has invested and believes they are a victim is not to “pay any additional fees or taxes to withdraw your money” (IC3, March 2023). That includes borrowing or cashing in savings to raise it. Operation Level Up, an FBI effort that contacts victims of crypto investment fraud, lists among its 2025 cases, in the FBI’s annual report, a victim stopped from cashing out $750,000 from a retirement account and another stopped from taking a loan to send $400,000 to a scammer.
- Keep everything, now. These sites close without notice. Save screenshots of the balance and the withdrawal messages, the website address and the app’s name, the chat history, and the details of every transfer. For crypto, the FBI asks for the addresses, the amount and type of coin, the date and time, and the transaction ID, or hash (IC3, August 2023). The IC3 does not accept attachments, so originals stay with you in case an investigating agency asks for them.
- Tell the bank and the exchange you paid from. The FTC’s advice for a crypto payment is to contact the exchange or ATM operator immediately, tell them the transaction was fraudulent and ask for it to be reversed, while noting that crypto payments lack the legal protections of cards (FTC, what to do if you were scammed). A transfer on the chain itself cannot be reversed, as the IC3’s crypto page notes. For a bank transfer, the FBI’s report is blunt that “time is of the essence”: contact the bank at once and ask it to recall the funds, then file a complaint with the full transaction details, since the IC3’s Recovery Asset Team may be able to help banks and law enforcement freeze them.
- Report it. In the US, file with the IC3, which accepts complaints from people in other countries too, and with the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov; the CFTC takes complaints at cftc.gov/complaint. In the UK, Report Fraud replaced Action Fraud as the national reporting service in December 2025; in Scotland, reports go to Police Scotland on 101 (Stop! Think Fraud). Elsewhere, the national police. The CFTC’s romance-fraud advisory also suggests reporting to the social media or dating platform where contact began and to the exchange involved.
- Expect a second approach. The last tip in the 2023 FBI alert is not to pay for services that claim they can recover lost funds. Such offers are aimed at people who have already lost money, and the FBI calls them a ruse to revictimise them (IC3, April 2025), the subject of crypto recovery scams.